Margaritaville Times Square Review: A NYC Beachy Escape

Margaritaville Times Square is a full-on beach party in the middle of Midtown with beachy themed restaurants, rooftop cocktails, and city views all rolled into one. I spent a lot of time at the heated rooftop pool sipping margaritas and laughing every time I thought about the 30-foot Statue of Liberty raising a margarita glass in their lobby. It’s way more fun than I expected from a Times Square hotel.

SheBuysTravel Tip: Skip the airport stress — Lyft’s On-Time Pickup Promise guarantees your scheduled ride shows up within 10 minutes of your pickup time. If it doesn’t? You’ll get Lyft Cash. You can schedule up to 90 days in advance and even lock in your rate. Use code SBT25 to save 25% off ONE scheduled ride to the airport.

Spacious Rooms with a View

• Spacious by New York standards:  comfortably fit a King bed, bathroom large enough for 2, and more than enough storage for clothes and luggage.

• Floor-to-ceiling windows with an insane view of the midtown skyline

Join our Travel Tribe! Sign up for our newsletter now!

Dining & Drinks

This resort doesn’t just have one bar—it has four different restaurants and bars to keep the party going:

• Margaritaville Restaurant: Must visit for a photo opp with the MASSIVE Statue of Liberty replica. I recommend the salty fried pickles with a marg!
• LandShark Bar & Grill: Outdoor heated pool, bar and casual bites. The nacho plate I demolished could have fed 5 people.

• 5 O’Clock Somewhere Bar: Incredible rooftop views + frozen drinks.

• License to Chill Bar: Indoor/outdoor bar with a quieter spot for a pre-dinner drink, outdoor seating.
  

What We Loved

• Location: Right in the heart of Times Square, Broadway theaters just steps away
• Rooftop Pool: A rare find in NYC, with city views and easy access to drinks
• Themed Fun: From beach signs to that over-the-top Statue of Liberty, it’s unapologetically Margaritaville
• Variety of Bars: Options for everything from morning coffee to rooftop cocktails
• Staff Vibe: Friendly, casual, and helpful without being stiff
  

What to Know Before You Book

• This is not a quiet retreat—it’s lively and themed from top to bottom
• Expect casual dining, not fine dining
• Rooftop pool is heated but gets busy in summe
• Times Square energy doesn’t stop outside, so prepare for crowds
  

Read More

• New York City 3-Day Itinerary: Where to Go and How to Get There
• The Best Spas in New York City for Some Me-Time in the Metropolis!
• The Ride NYC: More Than a Bus Tour
• Hidden Gems in New York City – Secrets the Locals Know